Skip to content

Impact Windows vs. Shutters: Which One Should You Choose

window shutters

Share This Post

The hurricane season can be a nerve-racking time for homeowners, especially those living in areas prone to severe weather conditions. Protecting your property from high winds, flying debris, and other hazards is crucial to ensure your safety and prevent costly damages. When it comes to hurricane protection, two popular options are impact windows and shutters. But how do you choose between the two?

Impact Windows

Impact windows are designed to withstand the impact of debris and high winds. They are made of laminated glass and reinforced with a polyvinyl butyral (PVB) layer that holds the glass together even if it is shattered. Impact windows are permanently installed and provide a clear view of the outside. They are also energy efficient and can reduce your energy bills by 30 percent.

Advantages of Impact Windows

1. Permanent Protection: Impact windows provide a permanent solution to protect your property from hurricanes and other severe weather conditions. Once installed, you don’t have to worry about putting up shutters or other temporary solutions.

2. Energy Efficiency: Impact windows can help you save money on your energy bills by keeping your home cool in the summer and warm in the winter. They are designed to block UV rays and reduce heat transfer.

3. Noise Reduction: Impact windows can also reduce noise from outside sources, such as traffic or construction.

Disadvantages of Impact Windows

1. High Cost: Impact windows are more expensive than shutters, and the installation process can be more complicated.

2. Limited Design Options: Impact windows are available in limited design options, and they may not match the existing aesthetic of your property.

3. Limited Functionality: Impact windows cannot be opened like traditional windows, which may be a disadvantage for some homeowners.


Shutters are an affordable and flexible option for protecting your property from severe weather conditions. They are available in various materials, including aluminum, steel, and vinyl. Shutters can be permanently installed or put up before a storm and taken down afterward.

Advantages of Shutters

1. Affordable: Shutters are a more affordable option than impact windows, and they can be installed quickly.

2. Aesthetic Appeal: Shutters come in a variety of colors and designs, and they can enhance the beauty of your property.

3. Functionality: Shutters can be opened and closed depending on your needs. They can also provide privacy and shade.

Disadvantages of Shutters

1. Maintenance: Shutters require maintenance, especially if they are made of metal. They need to be cleaned and painted regularly to prevent rust and corrosion.

2. Storage: If you choose temporary shutters, you need to store them when not in use. This can be a hassle, especially if you have limited storage space.

3. Limited Energy Savings: Shutters do not offer the same level of energy savings as impact windows, as they do not provide as tight a seal.

Final Thoughts

Both impact windows and shutters offer protection against severe weather conditions. The decision on which one to choose depends on your budget, aesthetic preferences, and functionality needs. Impact windows may be the best option if you are looking for a permanent solution and want to save on energy bills. However, if you are looking for an affordable and flexible solution that can enhance your property’s beauty, shutters may be the better choice. Regardless of which option you choose, it’s essential to invest in protection for your property to ensure your safety and peace of mind during severe weather conditions.

Get the best impact windows and doors for your home from Precision Aluminum & Remodeling. We are a veteran-owned, family-operated company with over 60 years of experience in the business. We take pride in providing the best quality service to our customers with even better pricing. Get a free consultation now!

More To Explore